Login Survey

Social Sign-on & New Account Creation

Use your arrow keys ↔ ↕
Press ESC for overview
Notes in pink on screenshots

Code Academy

Clean social sign-on integration on both mobile and desktop. Does show some pains from integration. Decent brand integrity.

Down ↓ to view.

Code Pen

Github only. Nice integration (except for the hard-to-find free plan). Good brand integrity.

Down ↓ to view.

Code School

Not great on mobile. Shows some pain from integration maintenance. Minimal brand confict, but identity gets messy.

Down ↓ to view.

Doodle

Clean implementation. Nice notice that they won't ever post or share. Curious choice to favor Sign-in and to hide sign-up. Although, new users can schedule an event before they sign up -- maybe that's the goal.

Down ↓ to view.

Duolingo

Process completely failed. Tested on Safari logged out of google as if on a public computer. With 2-factor, this is a similar experience to Persona.

Down ↓ to view.

IFTTT

Even though IFTTT connects to every service imaginable, they don't offer social sign-on. Responsive and elegant. If you've never tried their work flow to make a recipe, you gotta try it. Choose Email as your IF.

Down ↓ to view.

JS Fiddle

No social sign-on. A mess on mobile. Captcha's are nice in theory...

Down ↓ to view.

Khan Academy

Mobile starts off nice, then gets odd. Includes option for teachers and parents to sign up youth. Integration looks like it needs an update. Nice tooltip that they won't post without permission.

Down ↓ to view.

THE END?

@mw | mw@mofo